Oh, but she has sung for all of us. One of the tragedies of Mom's life is that she chose the career to please her Parents. Mom had, and has a good singing voice--it was clear, and strong when she was young, and Mom wanted to be a big band singer. She read all the Jazz magazines published in the 1930's-40's and listened to all the bands on the radio, usually while doing her homework.
Unfortunately, my Grandfather worked for an executive, Howard Cullman, who produced many Broadway musicals of the 1940's and '50's. Mr. Cullman was described as 'Broadway's Number One Angel" but I guess his conduct was less than angelic because Grandpa forbade my Mom to pursue a career in show business--only 'loose women' went into show business. So, Mom, being a good daughter, went to the College of New Rochelle, and then got her Masters from Teacher's College, Columbia University. She taught in the public schools until she married my Dad, Bob Michaels, in 1953.
And she has sung whenever she got the chance. On long car rides--when we children had lapsed into a stupor after 'don't stare at me' or 'she's sitting on my side of the car'. I knew every single Johnny Mercer song--that Lady of One Thousand Songs had nothing on my Mom. What's worse is when she hums--it's more like a grunt, and provides a downbeat by slapping on her thighs.
Oddly enough, I began to read "Legends' by James Kirkwood and recognized many of Mom's character traits in Mary Martin. The ladylike demeanor--the inability to admit to any genuine emotion, especially a strong one. They both have a talent of getting their own way by a sweet, refined air that will brook no opposition. Weatherford, Texas was not emotionally distant from Bay Ridge, Brooklyn ( Mom's birthplace--Miss Martin was from Texas).
My theory is women whose mothers were raised in the 19th century learned at home and school to get their way without being openly assertive. They used other methods--charm, emotional blackmail, singing, manipulation--all the traditional female wiles. I did come of age during the 70's, when the Feminist movement was in full swing, so I've found it difficult to relate to Mom's passive aggressiveness. If you can teach an old dog new tricks, this old bitch is going to be more patient and understanding with Mom.